I am remembering Manchester: we are trundling round town and I’m telling Simon about my first foray into the city.
‘I remember standing beneath the viaduct at Castlefield, listening to music ricochet off all that industrial architecture and dancing with the Dpercussion masses. I couldn’t imagine any other city in Britain pulling it off.’
Simon nods as he steers the buggy along Whitworth Street. I remember, too, stumbling along this same street years ago, on my way to the station after a job interview, entranced by the buildings looming up: all those textile warehouses built in homage to the god of commerce.
But now that I live here, the place strikes me as little more than a village. It’s not so much six degrees of separation but one. This is a city where you can sit in a café or a pub and talk about some bright idea and not long afterwards you’ll have found a loose group of people who can help you make it happen.
‘Like who?’ asks Simon, and I begin to reel off a list: the blog awards, Rainy City Stories, No Point Not Being Friends, In The City, Club Brenda, Unconvention, Sounds from the Other City, Futuresonic, the Literature Festival and even Dpercussion. This is what keeps me in Manchester, I think, the sense that, creatively speaking, we’ve never had it so good.
We head to Urbis for some art and grub. Inside, Milo plumps for a toasted cheese sandwich which, when it arrives, he promptly tries to chuck on the floor.
‘But Milo,’ says I, ‘it’s got dead flies on it. Don’t you want to eat some nice crispy dead flies?’
The boy peers suspiciously at the black sesame seeds that dot the top of the toastie, then demolishes it, only stopping to mumble ‘dead fly’ occasionally before shoving in another mouthful.
Flies ingested, we head up to Videogame Nation, where Milo plays with pixels and I remember why it is I hated Pacman. We dip into the Best of Manchester exhibition, too, me marvelling at just how beautiful Natalie Curtis’ pictures are and Simon, for someone who is almost always deeply unimpressed by The Youth, reasonably impressed by the collective creative talents on display. Milo, for his part, just wants to drive his cars up and down the benches. We hang out at Urbis a fair bit and he knows the score: he gets to eat dead fly sandwiches and play with cars; mummy gets to drink coffee and play at being an art critic.
Urbis has had its faults: its rocky start in life, as a museum of it-didn’t-quite-know-what, has been well documented. But in the past couple of years Urbis has turned itself around – with exhibitions like Emory Douglas, Videogame Nation and the soon-to-open British Hip Hop show. And, although I have worked for Urbis in the past, I remain a critical soul: I like my art to be good and I like the places I hang out to be worth it. Urbis is not by any stretch perfect. It still has a way to go. But I thought it could get there.
It appears it’ll never get the chance: Manchester City Council wants to offload this particular financial burden onto the private sector by turning it into a football museum. For a city that is so good in so many ways, that has finally started to ‘get’ culture by investing in things such as MIF, and that has recently put itself forward as one of the UK’s first cities of culture, it seems a strange decision. Why should it be one or the other – why pit culture against football? Why not have both?
I ponder on this as we wander back downstairs. And as we leave I wonder whether I will be coming back here quite so much when Milo is a bigger boy; whether the Council’s grand plan will simply reinforce Manchester’s shopping-and-football stereotype, and whether or not the newest, edgiest art and cultural commentary won’t be found in this so-called original and modern city but elsewhere. Further south.
Ratings. Babychanging facilities: Yes. Cafe: Yes, one of my favourite in the city centre. Good kids’ selection of both hot meals and sarnies. Buggy-friendly? Yes. Cost: Free. Worth it? Yes. Until they turn it into a football museum (no date yet but I’ll keep you posted), this has some of the most interesting exhibitions in Manchester. They generally have an eye on what kids need, too: there are usually activities and interactives for all ages, plus, during half terms and holidays, daily workshops and soft play in the foyer (workshops around £3). A welcome respite from city centre shopping: go now before it’s too late.





Just one factual note, the football museum would be free…
Thanks for that – a news report I saw stated it’d be fee-paying (as per the Preston model). So if it won’t be generating any revenue (in the same way that Urbis is pretty much free to get into now), what’s the point – does it come with additional funding attached?
Preston’s free too. It has to be in exchaange for DCMS funding.
INcreased visitor numbers means increased revenue. Increased corporate bookings are likely. There’s also the opportunity to make some of the building more suitable as a visitor attraction.
We are also, of course, looking at how we continue to stage the exhibitions that would not be directly relevant to football. More on this if it develops.
free maybe but with no one in it. Football is about playing, watching and participating in it… maybe invest in a better outdoor play area around the URBIS but for gods sake – think about what you are proposing! A football museum? Words fail.
Aww, lovely post. Don’t know what we’ll do when it’s all different. There will definitely be a big Urbis-shaped hole in my (and Molly’s) Manchester day-to-day.
I know. Am gutted it’s going. Maybe we should open our own urban arts centre… (I’m only half-kidding. If I were any better at maths/had more time/could fill in funding apps I’d be there….).
People in Preston not too happy about it either: http://www.lep.co.uk/news/Sir-Tom-backs-football-museum.5665970.jp
I hope they do manage to keep some other exhibitions if the football museum ends up going ahead. I agree, the Emory Douglas one was fantastic – your mentioning it has reminded me that I need to get the print we bought from the giftshop framed!
Kath
Good reminder – I still have my ED print in a cardboard tube waiting to be framed!
[...] football museum bullshit By maxdunbar Travels With My Baby gets it right on the Urbis. Manchester City Council wants to offload this particular financial [...]
Ehm, thought it might be worth pointing out a couple of things to set your mind at ease!
1) All of Urbis isn’t being turned into the football museum – only part of it. So Urbis remains. The current attraction will share space with the new one.
2) So that means that football and culture will be sharing space, it’s the best of both worlds
3) The museum, if it comes, will be free.
4) More visitors will come to Urbis, which thereby secures its future.
It’s win win for Manchester!
Hi Urbis-and-football fan, and thanks for the comment.
It’s not a win-win, sadly: the remaining space for Urbis-style exhibitions after the football stuff goes in will be very small – one gallery max. as opposed to the current three/four. They don’t get to share – football hogs most of the space. And the exhibitions they will put on after the football museum opens will have to be linked in some way, i.e. take their lead from football culture, so look at things like George Best, social history of football, sports fashion and that sort of thing. So Urbis’ current scope – for shows that include American civil rights, hip hop, videogaming, TV, design, fashion and so on – will be severely curtailed. The Best of Manchester Awards and Catapault – which showcase emerging creative talent from young people and graduates in the city – will cease. Urbis as we know it won’t exist. Already, shows that were being planned for 2010 and 2011 have had to be scrapped – some top shows, too, ones that would have done Manchester proud.
Urbis already gets around 250,000 visitors a year – this is a fabulous figure in comparison to other regional art galleries (and puts many to shame). So I don’t think it’s down to numbers so much as the Council not having the confidence in the Urbis ‘product’. Which in my humble opinion is a shame, as I wonder when was the last time many of the powers-that-be actually went to an Urbis show? If they’d been to the Emory Douglas, for example, they would have been totally blown away.
But yes, you’re right, it will be free to get into – I got that wrong, and Urbis corrected me (see comments above) – will change that in my text now! And I should reiterate that I don’t have a problem with a football museum per se, it’s just I think Manchester will be poorer without Urbis’ ongoing exhibition programme.
A win win for Manchester would be a football museum *and* Urbis, not a football museum taking over Urbis.
Sorry Urbis and football-fan, but you’ve been mis-informed. All of the Urbis building will be turned over to football as ‘Ms avecbaba’ says.
While the Urbis team will be working on the presentation, and on the temporary exhibitions, these will be football themed. Yes, they’ll still be edgy, contemporary, etc, but they’ll be about football. Things like Emory and the promotion of the creative industries in the city just won’t fit. Which is why we’re starting to look at other space in the city.
what is there to say about football…? the type of leather used to craft a nice round bouncy shape? OR the millions spent of shifting men (and only men) from one club to another… the history of some shady manager who blows his cash on girls and *** booze and…. words fail me again.
why not be bolder and tear down the building and build a football academy that actually might have some results and visitors…!
the city wont win. it already lost when someone thought this was creative thinking. well done.
Such a lovely post.I hope they do manage to keep some other exhibitions if the football museum ends up going ahead.
You just made me get goosebumps about DPercussion. You are right, we are so lucky. Having worked in Urbis too, I know the way it makes art accessible to people who might not set foot in a conventional gallery. Who could forget the Hacienda Exhibition? Or the Peter Saville one? Or the Urban Gardeing one? Or ‘Play’? Damn, it can’t go, it just can’t. There’s the community work too, having just worked on Reclaim I can vouch for how crucial that is and what a perfect hub Urbis makes for it.
It can’t go, it just can’t, but tragically I think it will.